Doctor Who Season 6 Episode 8 Review: Let’s Kill Hitler

by Mo Fathelbab on August 28, 2011 · 7 comments

in BBC, Doctor Who

Welcome back, fellow Whovians! It’s been a few weeks since the last episode of Doctor Who. Hope you had an awesome summer and that you were able to avoid earthquakes, hurricanes, debt ceiling fights, and crappy movies about how awesome it was to be a servant. (Man, what a 2011 so far.) Now, before I begin, I’m going to let you take a moment to soak in everything that happened in the amazing Season 6.5 premiere, “Let’s Kill Hitler”.

Are you okay now?

Good.

doctor who

Since we last saw The Doctor (Matt Smith) and his companions (Karen Gillan, Arthur Darvill), we were hit with a whopper of a twist when it was revealed that River Song (Alex Kingston) was Amy and Rory’s daughter, Melody Pond. And even though Creepy Eye Patch Lady and The Silence has kidnapped the baby, our heroes know that they’ll eventually find her alive since the adult River is still around and has been going on various adventures with them.

“Let’s Kill Hitler” begins with Amy and Rory racing to meet The Doctor at a crop-circled wheat field as they continue their search for their infant daughter. Behind them is Amy’s previously unseen troublemaker best friend Mels (Nina Toussaint-White), who, in flashbacks, is obsessed with Teen Amy’s own obsession over the mysterious Time Lord and practically gets her to hook up with Rory (in a pretty funny scene that’s well played by Gillan and Darvill). Mels has stolen a sweet-looking car and is ready to go on her own adventure in the TARDIS, pointing a loaded weapon at The Doctor and saying:

“…. I’ve got a gun. What the hell? Let’s kill Hitler.” (Hence the episode’s title.)

Mels accidentally discharges the gun in the TARDIS, causing the blue box to crash in Adolf Hitler’s Berlin office in 1938, thwarting another attempt on his life, this time by another set of time travelers: a miniature people who travel around in a ship that disguises itself as some of the humans it encounters. This time, they’ve disguised their ship as a Nazi officer in order to get closer to the world’s worst dictator and off him. (By the way, who would have thought that showrunner Steven Moffat was a fan of the Eddie Murphy bomb Meet Dave?) Hitler freaks out, tries to shoot the ship-turned-Nazi officer but shoots Mels instead. Rory cold-clocks Hitler (a nice homage to Captain America), locks him a cupboard, and joins Amy and The Doctor as they witness a pretty awesome reveal:

A dying Mels regenerates into the Alex Kingston-version of Melody Pond, a/k/a River Song. So, it turns out that the woman who Amy named her child after was her child after all. But that’s not the awesome part of the pretty awesome reveal. What was truly awesome, from a fan’s point of view, were the following thing:

-We have a female Time Lord; the second remaining female Time Lord if we count The Doctor-Donna from Season 4’s “Journey’s End”.

-The little girl who called Richard Nixon in “The Impossible Astronaut” and then regenerated in a New York City street was indeed Melody Pond.

-At some point, Melody regenerated into a British-African female Time Lord named Mels.

-And now she’s River Song but with no memory of the River Song we’ve been following for the last three seasons.

Before I continue with this review, let me point out how overwhelming it was to not only see a female Time Lord, but a non-White one as well. Sure, we caught a glimpse of the somewhat diverse society of Gallifrey in Season 4’s “The End of Time”. There were Time Lords of color and we met someone who may have been The Doctor’s mother but Timothy Dalton’s Lord President did most of the talking before The Master took them all out. To have an actual living, breathing minority Time Lord –- in an episode where the characters meet the biggest, most evil bigot the world has ever known –- is sheer genius on Moffat and company’s part.

Anyway, that euphoria is short lived as River, experiencing a few kinks in her regeneration process and remembering that her sole mission is to kill The Doctor, poisons him (in another great Moffat-penned homage, this time of The Sixth Doctor’s homicidal nature immediately after his regeneration), and jumps out of Hitler’s office window. Amy and Rory chase after their crazed daughter. The miniature people recognize River as The Doctor’s killer -– for her supposed actions in Utah in 2011 (and in their eyes, she’s just as bad, if not worse, than Adolf Hitler) -– and do the same, this time with their ship disguised as Amy. (Two Karen Gillans for the price of one! It is a good day to be a fanboy!)

Meanwhile, The Doctor is dying but it’s too late for him to regenerate. He asks the TARDIS to help him find an antidote and instead it appears to him as past companions (best day ever for a fanboy!) before settling on the one The Doctor hasn’t screwed up yet: little Amelia Pond. She tells him coldly that he’s simply going to die. The Doctor then finds himself in bit of quandary: should he then allow his potential killer to get what she seemingly deserves? Or should he help preserve her life? It’s pretty much similar to the ultimate philosophical question regarding time travel: if there were time machines, should we jump into one with the specific purpose of killing Adolf Hitler?

Of course, The Doctor chooses to help River live and with the help of Amy and Rory — who wind up inside the ship disguised as Amy — stop the miniature people from “giving her Hell” (which seems to consist of actually burning her).

And then The Doctor then dies! He just fracking croaks! For the second time this season nonetheless! It’s sadsville all over again!

The compassion The Doctor showed River didn’t go unnoticed. After Amy helps her see her true self, River zaps the rest of her regeneration powers into The Doctor’s lifeless body –- through an intense Snow White-like kiss -– and he comes to. The Doctor is back and ready for more time-bending adventures that involve awesome catch phrases like “Shut up, Hitler!”

“Let’s Kill Hitler” does leaves us with some interesting things to ponder for the rest of the season. Firstly: River gives up her other lives to revive The Doctor only to supposedly kill him in 2011? WTF?

Secondly: we now know that The Silence isn’t an alien species but a fanatical religious order that’s out to kill The Doctor. Why?

And thirdly: where can a fanboy buy a robot Karen Gillan?

Until next week, fellow Whovians!

{ 7 comments }

Shiromi Arserio August 28, 2011 at 11:08 pm

I loved it. I can’t believe how much I’ve missed the Doctor. Having said that, the whole timey-wimey stuff is really starting to make my headspin. When does River actually end up killing the Doctor? And why doesn’t the Doctor even flinch when he learns that he can’t regenerate? I’m also hoping to see some mre stuff with River and her parents. She seems surprisingly single-minded when it comes to the Doctor, but doesn’t seem to give a fig about Rory and Amy.
http://igp-scifi.com/2011/08/dr-who-review-lets-kill-hitler/

Gavin August 28, 2011 at 11:36 pm

well my theory is that river is the impossible astronaut, and what we saw in episode one is where she kills him, i also bet that the doctor seen getting killed is a replica made from the flesh

Get A Free Walmart $1000 Gift Card August 29, 2011 at 2:23 am
tentativelyfrank August 29, 2011 at 2:31 pm

I wasted the entire morning pondering the many lives of River Song, and have come up with a timeline (of sorts) here:

http://theoncominghope.blogspot.com/2011/08/many-lives-of-river-song-or-thinking.html

Jacki Whitford September 1, 2011 at 3:23 am

Here is my two cents. I think the Silence sees The Doctor as the only one who can stop them from taking over the Universe, and figure they need another Time Lord to kill him. Now River is not really a Time Lord human, because as we saw she would just go insane like Doctor Donna did before The Doctor made her forget everything. River was conceived during time travel aboard the TARDIS so she has some time traveling TARDIS in her DNA. That was why she could regenerate. Now the number of times you can regenerate appears to vary. River supposedly gave up all of hers to save The Doctor, but The Doctor told Sarah on her show that it was a very large unlimited number. Maybe it is for him since he is 100% Time Lord, but River was only part TARDIS. 

Back to the Silence. They were probably not very happy that The Doctor stopped them from taking over the Earth in 1969, which probably stepped up their revenge plans using Amy’s baby. But there is something missing. The young woman who made the prayer leaf with River Song’s name on it associated The Doctor’s name with war, and as a great warrior and leader. The Doctor had no idea how that happened, so it appears he needs to find out how that part of his reputation grew. Somehow, somewhat the Silence see him as a threat to their plans.

Now is it the child Melody Pond who kills The Doctor in Silencio, Utah or a double flesh lookalike? And how does the impact the River/Doctor timeline?

FYI – Here is a River/Doctor timeline someone attempted before last week’s episode. 

http://images.geeknative.com.s3.amazonaws.com/geeknative.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/river-song-doctor-timeline.jpg

learn this here now December 4, 2014 at 4:33 pm

I simply want to say I am just beginner to weblog and seriously liked your blog site. Most likely I’m planning to bookmark your blog . You actually have impressive stories. Many thanks for sharing your blog.

Discover More December 4, 2014 at 6:12 pm

I simply want to mention I am just all new to blogs and absolutely liked this web blog. Almost certainly I’m want to bookmark your website . You absolutely have incredible well written articles. Thanks for revealing your web page.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: